Police said five men were arrested in the wake of the invasion.
The Rev. Craig Scott, pastor of St. Rita Catholic Church, was shot and the Rev. Marek Norjek was hit in the head.
Charged with attempted first degree murder and armed robbery on Thursday were 18-year-old Paul Antonio Clark, 21-year-old Larry Culbert, 18-year-old Ashunti Pearrie and a 17-year-old, all of Alexandria.
Another 17-year-old was booked with accessory after the fact and armed robbery.